Activist, writer, sex-positive feminist, single mother, sandgroper, grumpy old woman.

Tuesday, June 1, 2010

Bogan Bashing (Fuck the Poor)

Back in the 80s, bogans were characterised by their black stretch jeans, black DBs, black AC/DC (or Metallica, or Motley Crue, or Gunners) t-shirt, flanno overshirt and mullet. They listened to hard rock, drank copious amounts of beer, drove banged-up utes with big V8s, and...well, that's about it. They were just your average Aussie yobbos. In the area where I grew up, just about everyone could be considered a bogan. The clothes, the utes, the booze, the classic Aussie rock; all standard fare in Western Australian outback towns.

Today, the word 'bogan' has come to mean something else entirely. It's a little bit yobbo (clothes, booze, music), a little bit trailer trash (domestic violence, anti-social behaviour, uneducated, poor), a little bit dole bludger (unemployed, lazy, "having kids for the welfare") and a little bit redneck (politically conservative, white supremacist, xenophobic, sexist). Everything we hate about humanity, all wrapped up in one neat little flanno-clad package. How convenient.

But I wouldn't be so worked up about this if it was just a simple issue of semantics. Take a quick look around at the comments on news sites, blogger opinions, etc and you'll see it's so much more than that. This is real hatred. Take a comment I read today, for example (the catalyst for this angry rant):

"We should sterilise them. Seriously. Generation after generation of bogan filth, milking the welfare system and filling our prisons. It might sound over the top, but if these stupid sluts can't keep their legs closed, it's the only way to end the cycle. We have to stop them breeding".

Someone followed up that post with...

"Sterilisation? If a racehorse gets hurt and can't earn its owner money, they put it down. We're pouring millions into welfare and what do these bogan cunts give us in return? Nothing. Sterilisation's too good for them. We should be putting the bastards out of their misery".

Oh lordy, where do I start? I could remind people that forced sterilisation is a suggestion once made to solve the 'problem' of Aboriginal people and, later, the 'problem' of people with disabilities. I could point out that in these days of political correctness, there are very few minority groups that people would dare talk about in that way. But what I really want to draw your attention to is the central premise of both those These people hate these so-called 'bogans' because they're POOR.

When the hell did we become the sort of society that bashes people for living in poverty?

Australians have always been on the side of the battler. In fact, we're so obsessed with backing the underdog that cutting down Aussies who get too big for their boots is practically a national sport. As a nation, we don't like people who put themselves on a pedestal. We don't allow our politicians, our celebrities, our millionaires, or anyone else to lord it over us. A person may be richer, more powerful, more famous, or more beautiful than you, but they are never 'better' than you.

So, if our Prime Minister doesn't have the right to think he's better than the rest of us, what gives blue collar workers and housewives the right to think they're better than the average 'bogan'? When did it become ok for everyday folks to crap all over our nation's most vulnerable? When did it become ok to hate someone because they're destitute? If there was ever an example of 'un-Australian'...this is it. It goes against everything we've always claimed to believe in.

Interestingly, this hatred doesn't dissipate when the poor, lazy "filth" get off their butts and start earning the big bucks. 'Cashed up bogans', the media dubbed them - unskilled, uneducated, flanno-wearing men (and women) who work on the mines, often clearing over $120,000 a year. We hate them when they're poor, but we hate them just as much when they're rich. This time we apparently hate them because they don't deserve it. But I think it's more than that. I think we hate them because they dared to rise above their station. We don't want them sponging off the taxpayers, but we also don't want them having more money or power than 'respectable' folk. We want them to contribute, but they need to remember their place.

Sadly, due to the aforementioned cultural similarities between 'bogans' and rural West Aussies, country folk are also finding themselves the targets of anti-bogan abuse. A recent news story about the mass closure of Year 11&12 district high school programs across the state (another rant for another time), elicited reader comments that taxpayer funds were "wasted" on educating country people, that they didn't need high school qualifications to get work in the bush, that they might have to reconsider "popping out all those kids", and that they would just have to move to the city "but then they would have to actually get off their arses and get a job". Sound familiar?

I don't know what started this bogan-bashing trend and I really can't make sense of it. All I know is that the stigma and insults are making disadvantaged people's lives even harder than they already are.


  1. Hi, I'm new to your blog. I found this post interesting, but I disagree on two major points - 1) never look for rational comment on an online forum, and 2) being a 'bogan' in WA now isn't anything at all to do with being poor or even wearing flannel and listening to hard rock.

    Here in Perth, people are fed up with obnoxious loud-mouthed louts with no respect for anyone including themselves. This goes on at every socio-economic level. It's the tarted up Soccer Mum in Claremont who speeds her Beamer through a car park and almost takes out a small child; it's the drunken FIFO on r&r who carves up a quiet beach on a jet ski too close to swimming families. We've had enough of disrespectful, drunk, self-involved, arrogant prats with not a shred of common decency among them.

    I was raised by a divorced Mother, in a blue collar town with a bad reputation full of flannel and bourbon. Many of the friends I still have in that town are just as fed up as the rest of us. It may not be exclusive to WA, but it seems that the boom years have given everyone from Twiggy to the blokes who drive the buses a sense of entitlement. I've never seen this state so self-important and self-obsessed. It's like the entire place turned into a million Ben Cousins. And I love Cuz, but damn is he an arrogant wanker.

    All I'm saying is I don't agree that it's about the working class rising above their station. That's what I did, and I haven't copped it. You know why? I don't endanger people's lives or get violent and dangerous when I'm out or disturb my neighbourhood with cranked doof music until 4am when I'm home. That's a bogan. And the moronic comments you read online were absolutely uncalled for, but there's quite a few people out there who could use a lesson in respect.

    Thanks for your writing. You have an interesting style and you are quite clearly not a bogan.

    Tad Bentley

    1. Tad,

      You are spot on. Bogans are not difficult to identify and while this blog points out many characteristics that bogans have you must meet the said bogan in person to truly label them as such. I also advocate a bogan sterilisation plan but a voluntary one. It would be along the lines of the baby bonus when an identified bogan female is paid 10 - 20 thousand dollars to be sterilised. This would in turn save hundreds of thousands of dollars from the child welfare and protection, juvenile justice and eventually welfare and adult justice systems and save ordinary folk from having to live with throwbacks to the dark ages. This must be be put in place as soon as possible to slow the increasing percentage of bogans living among us in society.


    2. Hi Rick,

      I definitely don't support the idea of targeting one section of the community for sterilisation (and if I would include the men, not just women!)

      But I very much agree with the benefits of making sterilisation more accessible. It's a pet peeve of mine. I'm a single mother and I've been BEGGING for a hysterectomy for almost 16 years, but no doctor will let me. And I know many, many low-income women who have tried to make the same (sensible) choice to permanently avoid unwanted pregnancy and have also been denied.

      It's about time the medical profession stopped treating women like children and let us make the best decision for our own bodies and our own families. I think a lot of poor women would take up the offer if it was freely available, even without financial inducements.